The connection between Left pondering and excessive neuroticism (as a proper character trait) is without doubt one of the most underdiscussed but necessary themes in American politics (to be clear, the Proper has its personal pathologies as effectively). Right here is one excerpt from Matt’s newest Substack (gated):
However I need to discuss one thing Goldberg mentions however doesn’t give attention to: a 2021 paper by Catherine Gimbrone, Lisa Bates, Seth Prins, and Katherine Keyes titled “The politics of melancholy: Diverging tendencies in internalizing signs amongst US adolescents by political opinions.” The CDC survey doesn’t ask teenagers about their political opinions, however Gimbrone et. al. discover not solely divergence by gender, however divergence by political ideology. Breaking issues down by gender and ideology, they discover that liberal ladies have the very best improve in depressive have an effect on and conservative boys have the least. However liberal boys are extra depressed than conservative ladies, suggesting an necessary unbiased function for political ideology.
A few of it could be choice impact, with progressive politics turning into a extra congenial dwelling for people who find themselves depressing. However I feel a few of it’s poor habits by grownup progressives, lots of whom now valorize depressive have an effect on as an indication of political dedication. The factor about melancholy, although, is that it’s unhealthy.
…progressive institutional leaders have particularly taught younger progressives that catastrophizing is an efficient strategy to get what they need…
Among the finest and most necessary items you’ll learn this yr. I’d go as far to say that you just can not perceive the American public mental sphere and not using a grasp of the shut connection between Left pondering and excessive neuroticism. I’d add that incorporating gender expectations into Matt’s evaluation would give it but extra explanatory energy. When you see all this, you may by no means look away once more and overlook it…